Microsoft 365 · Permissions
Will Microsoft Copilot show staff files they shouldn't see?
Not files they lack permission to open. But it can find, in seconds, a file they could always open and never knew was there. Microsoft says generative AI "amplifies the problem and risk of oversharing".12
In a firm that holds client files, loose permissions become a client-confidentiality problem. That applies to any AI platform connected to SharePoint, not only Copilot.
From client work, not theory. We have had to answer these questions for a client in a regulated industry, inside a working Microsoft 365 set-up and with the people who run it. Every statement about Microsoft, Anthropic and OpenAI was then checked against the company's own documentation on the date below.
Where does oversharing come from?
Content shared with the built-in group "Everyone except external users" is, in Microsoft's words, "effectively public" inside the firm. Our reading of Microsoft's pages is that Copilot can then surface it for any member of staff who asks.41
An organisation-wide sharing link works differently. Microsoft says such a link does not add the file to the firm-wide index; only people who open the link have it added to their own index.5
Microsoft's own advice is to make "Specific people" the default for sharing links and to hide broad options such as "Everyone except external users".6
Which Microsoft tools help, and what do they need?
Microsoft's deployment guidance for Copilot starts with remediating oversharing, then setting guardrails.7
SharePoint Advanced Management, which reports on overshared sites, is listed with Microsoft Copilot licences. Microsoft's page lists enterprise plans as the base licences; we could not confirm from it whether Business Premium with Copilot qualifies.8
Restricted Content Discovery hides sites from Copilot without changing permissions, and Microsoft calls it a temporary control. Restricted SharePoint Search limits search to up to 100 sites, and Microsoft says it "isn't a security boundary".910
Purview data loss prevention that stops Copilot processing labelled files and emails is not included in Microsoft 365 Business Basic, Standard or Premium, or in E3. It is included in E5.11
What do Australian rules add?
Tax practitioners must get each client's permission before disclosing their information to a third party, which the Tax Practitioners Board says can include entering it into AI tools, depending on how they are configured and used. Permission may come through the engagement letter.1213
The legal regulators of NSW, WA and Victoria say solicitors cannot safely enter confidential or privileged client information into public AI tools, and must review the contract terms of any commercial AI tool used with client information.14
Legal professional privilege depends on confidentiality. Our view, not a court ruling: a privileged file left open to the whole firm, and found by an AI assistant, is harder to treat as confidential.
The OAIC recommends that organisations do not enter personal information, and particularly sensitive information, into publicly available AI tools.15
From 10 December 2026, Privacy Act entities that use computer programs to make, or substantially assist, decisions that significantly affect people must say so in their privacy policy (APP 1.7 to 1.9). Small businesses under $3 million turnover are generally exempt, with exceptions such as health service providers.16 Check whether the duty applies to you →
What to fix before switching Copilot on
- Run the data access governance reports for sites shared with "Everyone except external users" or "Everyone", and fix client and HR folders first.4
- Make "Specific people" the default sharing link, and hide the broadest options.6
- Check which tools your licences include before relying on them: SharePoint Advanced Management, and Purview DLP for Copilot.811
- Check your engagement letters and client terms cover the AI tools you use, whichever platform they are on.1214
- Run the same checks before connecting Claude, ChatGPT or any other AI platform to SharePoint.
Fair to Microsoft
When is Copilot alone the right call?
- Your permissions are already clean: client folders shared only with the people on each matter or engagement.
- You have, or will buy, the licences for SharePoint Advanced Management and Purview controls, and someone to run them.
- You want one vendor, one contract and one admin centre, and you value that more than choice of model or tool.
Common questions
Can Copilot see files a user doesn't have access to?
No. Microsoft says Copilot only surfaces data the user has at least view permission to. The risk is files they do have access to but should not, which Copilot finds far faster than browsing.
Does a "people in your organisation" link expose a file to everyone through Copilot?
Not according to Microsoft. Such a link does not add the file to the firm-wide index; only people who open the link have it added to their own. Content shared with "Everyone except external users" is a different matter: Microsoft calls it effectively public inside the firm.
Does using Claude or ChatGPT avoid the oversharing problem?
No. Their Microsoft 365 connectors use each person's existing permissions too. Fix permissions before connecting any AI platform.
Do accountants need client consent to use AI?
The Tax Practitioners Board says tax practitioners need each client's permission before disclosing their information to a third party, which can include entering it into AI tools depending on configuration. An engagement letter can provide it.
Does CoterieLabs sell Copilot, ChatGPT or Claude?
No. CoterieLabs is an independent AI implementation consultancy in Sydney. We are not a Microsoft, Anthropic or OpenAI partner or reseller, and we earn nothing from any licence. We start from the work a firm wants done, then choose the tool.
Sources
- Microsoft Learn: Data, privacy and security for Microsoft Copilot. Read on 11 November 2026. Page dated 4 November 2026.
- Microsoft Learn: Microsoft Purview data security and compliance protections for generative AI apps. Read on 11 November 2026.
- Microsoft Learn: Data access governance: site permissions report. Read on 11 November 2026.
- Microsoft Learn: Data access governance reports. Read on 11 November 2026.
- Microsoft Learn: Semantic index for Copilot. Read on 11 November 2026.
- Microsoft Learn: Optimise SharePoint for Copilot. Read on 11 November 2026.
- Microsoft Learn: Secure and govern Microsoft Copilot: foundational deployment guidance. Read on 11 November 2026.
- Microsoft Learn: SharePoint Advanced Management. Read on 11 November 2026.
- Microsoft Learn: Restricted Content Discovery. Read on 11 November 2026.
- Microsoft Learn: Restricted SharePoint Search. Read on 11 November 2026.
- Microsoft Learn: Microsoft Purview service description. Read on 11 November 2026. Page dated 6 November 2026; see the table under "Data Loss Prevention (DLP) for Microsoft Copilot".
- Tax Practitioners Board: TPB(GS) 55/2026: Use of artificial intelligence and the Code of Professional Conduct. Read on 11 November 2026. Issued 22 July 2026.
- CoterieLabs Field Notes: The AI in your accounting software is already a compliance risk. Our Field Note; its figures were re-checked at the original source on 11 November 2026.
- Law Society of NSW, Legal Practice Board of WA and Victorian Legal Services Board + Commissioner: Statement on the use of artificial intelligence in Australian legal practice. Read on 11 November 2026. Joint statement of 6 December 2024.
- Office of the Australian Information Commissioner: Guidance on privacy and the use of commercially available AI products. Read on 11 November 2026. Published 21 October 2024. Read as archived by the Internet Archive, because the site blocks automated readers.
- CoterieLabs Field Notes: From December, every AI decision about a client needs disclosure. Our Field Note; its figures were re-checked at the original source on 11 November 2026.
AI governance · Before the tools
Set the rules before you switch it on.
We help firms decide who may use which AI tool with which client information, fix the permissions that matter, and keep a record of how AI-assisted work is checked. The same rules apply whichever platform you choose.
See AI governance for firms