← Field Notes

AI Compliance & Regulation

Can Tax Agents Be Fined for AI Mistakes? Yes, Up to $910,000

Since 1 October, breaching the TPB Code is a civil penalty: up to $910,000 for an individual tax agent. What that means for how your practice uses AI.

In short. Yes. Since 1 October 2026, failing to comply with the Tax Practitioners Board's Code of Professional Conduct is a civil penalty in its own right, with a maximum of 2,500 penalty units ($910,000) for an individual and 50,000 ($18.2 million) for a company. The TPB's AI guidance says an AI error doesn't remove your Code obligations, so an unchecked AI-prepared return is now a penalty exposure, not just a reputational one.

Does software help decide things about your customers or staff? From 10 December 2026 your privacy policy may have to say so. Six questions give a likely answer.

Take the check →

The Code now has a price tag

Since 1 October, a tax or BAS agent who breaches the Code of Professional Conduct can be taken to the Federal Court for a civil penalty of up to $910,000. For a company, the ceiling is $18.2 million. Until this year, a Code breach meant a caution, conditions on your registration or, at worst, losing it. Now it can mean a court-ordered penalty.

That matters for AI because the Tax Practitioners Board has already said, in writing, that an AI error is your error. Put those two facts together and the question for every practice using AI to prepare returns, BAS or advice is no longer "is this efficient?" It's "could I show the Board how this answer was checked?"

$910,000

Max civil penalty, individual

2,500 penalty units

$18.2M

Max civil penalty, company

50,000 penalty units

1 Oct 2026

Applies to conduct from

Schedule 1 commencement

What changed

The Treasury Laws Amendment (Strengthening Accountability for Tax Adviser Misconduct and Other Measures) Act 2026, the response to the PwC tax leaks matter, passed the Senate on 10 September. Its first schedule commenced on 1 October and applies to conduct from that date. It inserts a new section 50-31 into the Tax Agent Services Act 2009, making failure to comply with the Code a contravention in its own right.

Per SMS Magazine's summary of the Bill, civil penalties rise from 250 to 2,500 penalty units for individuals and from 1,250 to 50,000 for bodies corporate, including firms structured as partnerships or trusts. At the Commonwealth penalty unit of $364 that applies from 1 July 2026, that's the $910,000 and $18.2 million above. The Board must investigate before it goes to court. It also gains infringement notices for specified Code breaches (The Firm reports these include failing to keep your knowledge and skills current and failing to keep proper client records), enforceable undertakings and interim suspensions of up to 90 days.

AI for accountants in Australia: where the exposure sits

The Act never mentions AI. It doesn't need to. The TPB's finalised guidance, TPB(GS) 55/2026, maps AI use onto existing Code obligations: competence, reasonable care, confidentiality and record-keeping. Its core line is that AI mistakes do not remove a practitioner's obligations under the Code or responsibility for the advice given. We covered the confidentiality side in what accounting firms should tell clients about AI.

Three habits now carry real penalty exposure. A junior pastes a client question into a chatbot and sends the answer on: that's a reasonable-care problem under Code item 10. A deduction is claimed because an AI tool "found" it, with nothing on file to show why: that's a records problem, and one of the breaches eligible for an infringement notice. Client files go into a free tool that trains on inputs: that's confidentiality.

None of these is an argument for switching AI off. AI isn't the risk; unchecked AI is. The point is that the controls around AI are no longer optional housekeeping. They are your evidence. If you want a second pair of eyes on yours, book a call and we'll walk through your current setup.

What the guidance doesn't do for you

TPB(GS) 55/2026 tells you which obligations apply. It doesn't tell you which tools in your stack already send client data to a model, how to configure your practice software so AI-assisted work leaves an audit trail, or how to build a review step that doesn't wipe out the time AI saved. That's implementation, and it's where most small practices stall. The AI already embedded in your ledger and email platforms is part of it, as we noted in the compliance risk inside your accounting software.

What to do before the next lodgement peak

List every AI tool your team touches, including features switched on inside software you already pay for. Mark which ones see client data. Pick one approved tool for client work and ban the rest for client data. Then add one line to your file notes: "AI used, for what, checked by whom." That single line is the difference between showing reasonable care and asserting it. It also feeds straight into the conversation with your professional indemnity insurer, who will ask the same question the Board would.

Our AI services for accounting firms start there: the tool inventory, the approved-tool decision and one workflow with a review step built in, measured before anything wider is rolled out.

Key takeaways

01From 1 October 2026, failing to comply with the TPB Code of Professional Conduct is a civil penalty under new section 50-31 of the Tax Agent Services Act 2009.
02Maximum penalties are 2,500 penalty units ($910,000) for an individual and 50,000 ($18.2 million) for a body corporate, at the $364 penalty unit.
03The TPB's AI guidance, TPB(GS) 55/2026, says AI errors do not remove Code obligations: competence, reasonable care, confidentiality and record-keeping all apply.
04A file note recording which AI was used, for what, and who checked it is the cheapest evidence of reasonable care a practice can create.

Common questions

Can a tax agent be penalised for an AI mistake in Australia?

Yes. The TPB's guidance says AI errors don't remove a practitioner's Code obligations, and since 1 October 2026 a Code breach can attract a civil penalty of up to 2,500 penalty units ($910,000) for an individual, after a TPB investigation and a Federal Court order.

Do BAS agents have the same AI obligations as tax agents?

Yes. Registered BAS agents are tax practitioners under the Tax Agent Services Act 2009 and are bound by the same Code of Professional Conduct, so the TPB's AI guidance and the new civil penalty apply to them as well.

Does the new TPB penalty regime apply to past work?

The new sanctions in Schedule 1 apply to conduct from 1 October 2026. Work done before then is assessed under the previous regime.

Sources

Assumptions & methodology
  1. Last reviewed 18 November 2026 · general information for Australian tax and BAS practitioners, not legal advice.
  2. Dollar figures are our conversion of the penalty units using the Commonwealth penalty unit of $364 that applies to conduct from 1 July 2026 (Crimes (Amount of a Penalty Unit) Instrument 2026). The Federal Court sets the actual penalty in any case; these are maximums.
  3. The 250 → 2,500 and 1,250 → 50,000 penalty-unit figures are as reported by SMS Magazine (8 July 2026) from the Bill. The 1 October 2026 commencement, section 50-31 and the examples of infringement-notice-eligible breaches are as reported by The Firm (5 November 2026), citing the Act (No. 86, 2026) on the Federal Register of Legislation. We could not retrieve the Act's full text directly.
  4. The three 'habits' are our illustrations of how Code items map to common AI use, not findings from a TPB case.
ShareLinkedInEmail

Field Notes are general commentary on AI trends for Australian businesses. They don’t constitute professional advice. Talk to your accountant, lawyer, or IT adviser before acting on anything specific to your situation.

If this applies to you

Could you show the Board how your AI-assisted work was checked?

We help Australian accounting and BAS practices use AI inside the Code: the tool inventory, the approved-tool decision and a review step that keeps the time savings. Book a call and we'll look at where your practice stands.

Don't miss the next one

Get each new Field Note in your inbox as it publishes — short, practical AI intelligence for business owners.